Useful facts for the unconventional environmentalist.

Key Indicators

Newsletter Sign up

Downloadable Almanac

Download a PDF file of the 2011 Almanac of Environmental Trends.

Home>Tailored to Whom?

Tailored to Whom?


January 07, 2011

by Holly Fretwell

A new ruling of the EPA that is supposed to reduce carbon emissions, the Tailoring Rule, may in fact increase emissions instead. The new ruling regulates carbon dioxide emissions under equal standing, but not all net emissions are equal.

Fuel sources from deep in the earth, such as coal and natural gas, produce a one-way flow of carbon to the atmosphere when considering a human time frame.  In contrast, energy created from biomass, such as burning small woody debris, results in net negative emissions. The forest recycles (if you will) the carbon. Growing trees removes carbon from the atmosphere storing it within their mass. Managing forests through planting, thinning, and removal of woody debris can enhance forest growth, which also increases carbon sequestration. Forest products retain the carbon. Energy created from burning biomass emits carbon dioxide, returning it to the atmosphere. The amount emitted from burning woody debris, however, is balanced by the amount sequestered in its growth. In this way, the biomass energy has a two way flow of carbon. It reduces carbon when growing and re-emits it into the atmosphere when burned.

Seeing the forest through the trees, biomass energy that displaces fossil energy reduces net emissions.  Yet, the EPA rule treats all emissions equal giving biofuels a relative disadvantage even though they may reduce overall emissions. The unintended consequences of the EPA ruling will likely result in an increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide emissions. A result that is the exact opposite of the rulings stated intentions.

One Embarcadero Center, Suite 350 • San Francisco, CA 94111 • (415) 989-0833